RH Reality Check
Font Size: A |  A |  A

Plans B Damned: The Quest for Emergency Contraception

Nikol Hasler's picture

The condom broke, came off, or in some other way malfunctioned. He was behind me and I couldn't tell he wasn't using one. We just got carried away and he didn't pull out in time. I forgot to take my birth control. I had an appointment to get on the pill, but we didn't wait.

There are a whole slew of reasons a woman might find herself in need of a morning after pill; emergency contraception; Plan B. But unless you have Plan B already waiting in your medicine cabinet, it is highly unlikely you'll get your hands on a morning-after pill the morning after.

I am a middle class 29 year old mother of three, living in the Midwest, who sees a physician regularly. I have kept up on the news about Plan B's availability over the counter at major drug stores. In my line of work, I regularly tell teens and young adults to always use protection, and tell girls of reproductive age who aren't so into the whole reproduction thing that they should be on birth control.

I encouraged young women and men to seek Plan B if their contraceptive method failed or they forgot to use contraception, telling them it was easy to obtain. But was it?

On a Tuesday morning at 7 a.m., I set out to discover just how easy it would be for me to get my hands on some emergency contraception. It all started with a web search.

Google: Plan B, Wisconsin, Over the Counter

My Internet search lead me to the Plan B website, which was helpful in telling me how the medication worked and what to expect after taking the two twelve-hour staggered doses of the hormone used in birth control pills at a super concentrated dose. When it came to where I could find the medication, I expected a zip code look up function. When I saw that no such function existed, I started to call the local pharmacies.

The sweet sounding girl who answered the phone, didn't know what the hell I was talking about, and then ran off to ask the pharmacist, told me that I needed to get a prescription from my doctor. Given that I had just read that Plan B was available over-the-counter, this seemed strange to me, but given that this pharmacy indubitably deals with such requests frequently, I took the girl's word for it. I called my primary physician's office.

"Does Dr. M have any openings today?"

"Why, yes, he sure does," responds the receptionist. "And your name? Okay, Nikol, what do you need to see him for today?"

"Contraception. Birth Control. It is urgent that I see him today."

"Hmm. Will you hold please? I don't think we... I mean, appointments are..."

So I hold. I listen to a soothing bit of elevator music and a woman talking about proper nutrition. Just as I am really getting into it and considering if my calcium supplement is really that great, the receptionist breaks back in.

"Sorry, Nikol. We don't have openings for that purpose today. I can get you in to see him in, oh, two weeks."

"I'd be happy to do that, but for right now I need to know if he can call in a prescription for Plan B for me."

"What's Plan B?"

"Emergency contraception."

A moment passes where I hear her take this in. It sounds as if she may have breathed in a bit of potato chip. There is some coughing, but not the hearty, openly hacking kind. I am wondering why she is eating potato chips so early in the morning, and thinking of referring her to the hold message so she can better understand the importance of a proper breakfast. Then I realize she is making that noise due to mental discomfort.

"Ohhh. Oh. Oh, well then I will get this message to him right away. Yes, right away."

She seems lost, so I think for her.

"Do you need to know which pharmacy to call and the best number to reach me at? And should we go ahead and schedule that follow up so I don't have to bother you with this call again?"

"You still want to?"

I am silent. Does she think I am strictly an emergency kind of woman? Does she think I wanted to just give her a jingle every time I had a semen mishap? Perhaps she and I will get familiar with this process. I can imagine dialing her up. "Hey, Janine. It's me. You know who, silly! Yes, it is that time of month again. Oh, stop it. Stop it! You'd love this one. A real cutey."

We schedule the appointment and I hang up to ponder how I would be feeling if I were really worried about getting knocked up. I wait for the call letting me know that the prescription has been called in. When the return call comes, it's not the receptionist but a prerecorded message: "Please call me back. I see here in my notes that you have an appointment but want a Plan B."

I call back and hold hold hold only to be told that they are really busy today and will call back. This time I decide that I will use my wait time to contact the local Planned Parenthood. I am surprised to find that there is one very near my house.

Planned Parenthood sends me into into button pressing limbo. When I press "2" as indicated, that recorded voice tells me I have selected an invalid entry. When I press "0" for a person, I am directed into voice mail. I call back and restart my button pressing.

Once I reach a real person things look promising. All I have to do is come in with a photo i.d. proving that I am over 18 and fill out a bunch of paperwork; then they will give me the drug and tell me how to use it. Without my prompting, the woman on the phone talks about the cost.

"We can fund some of the cost, so it is going to cost between twenty five and forty dollars. You need to bring in the past two months' pay stubs and proof that you were born in Wisconsin."

"What if I am under 18? Not that I am, I was just wondering."

"Well, you would need a prescription."

Meanwhile, a nurse from my doctors's office calls back and tells me she is confused. A note informed her that I have made an appointment, but need Plan B. Given her response, I assume the desk clerk has not capitalized Plan or B.

"So, what is your plan b?" she asks me.

"No. I need Plan B. A prescription."

"A prescription for what?"

"Plan B."

"What is that plan?"

Can we say Abbott and Costello meets tragic lack of education regarding this drug?

"Emergency contraception. It is called Plan B. I called the pharmacy and they said I need a prescription."

"Oh. Wait. Did you have unprotected sex?"

"Well, er, see. There was a bit of a catastrophe. And I need the prescription."

I feel ashamed as she asks me if I usually have unprotected sex and whether I considered using birth control. That shame is taken over by my amusement at having used the word catastrophe. Being a visually imaginative person, I am seeing a typhoon of semen ripping its way through a island-like vaginal cavity, destroying everything in its path.

"Obviously I don't want to have this conversation ever again. I made an appointment to talk to Dr. M about birth control."

"Okay. Well, I need to talk to him about this."

"Yes, you would," I respond. "He would need to be the one writing the scrip."

My shame returns. Here I am, a grown woman asking for birth control that I don't even really need, yet I cannot shake this feeling that I am the town harlot in a back alley looking for the seedy looking fellow with a rusty coat hanger. She may have been right to imply that grown people should know how to avoid this situation in the first place, but perhaps a bit more professionalism and less judgment in her tone would have been appropriate.

Finally the nurse calls again, to inform me that I can get Plan B over the counter. When I tell her that the pharmacy told me otherwise, she says that some pharmacies refuse to fill the prescription or to offer it over the counter based on their moral beliefs.

I call the Pharmacy #1 again. I tell them that I don't need a prescription and they tell me that I do. I mention that I am over eighteen and they tell me that they don't have any in stock.

I have more luck at the second pharmacy I call, but the salesclerk tells me they only have one more in stock, so I should come in soon. What kind of strange sales pitch is that? Come in quick, folks, all the emergency contraception is flying off the shelves this summer! I can hear "Time of the Season" running behind that ad.

I go to the closest pharmacy to the grocery store because I need to pick up some fresh basil. While waiting in line I think of all of the people also there, waiting on their various medications, and I wonder how many of them have even heard of Plan B, and, of those who have, how many realize that it isn't an abortion pill.

When the fresh, bright-faced Midwestern college student calls me to the register, I say confidently, "I am here to pick up Plan B."

She moves to her computer habitually asking, "And how do you spell the last name?"

"No. I need Plan B. Over the counter."

Bless her, too, because when the realization hits her about what I need she seems almost proud to get it for me. She tells me she likes my hand bag and tries not to linger on the guy I am there with -- who is purposefully checking out the personal lubrication and condom area.

Forty-three dollars and change, and an i.d. check later, I am told to move to the side so the pharmacist can discuss the medication with me.

"Have you ever taken this before?" The pharmacist turns to me, but focuses on something that I assume is fascinating just beyond my head. I turn to look at it, too, but I guess I don't find local analgesics as fascinating as this dude.

The best bit of information he gives me is that if I should happen to vomit within 20 minutes of taking the first pill, I should take the second right away. Oh, and he adds, "This isn't to be used for the, uh, whole time or anything."

I am officially feeling ashamed at this point. I didn't know that was possible for me, but something about the tone of the pharmacist's voice as he speaks down to me like I am some sort of idiot who cannot even manage to use protection just brings it home. How must other women feel as the pharmacists of the world give them the stink eye and speak really slowly to them?

When my boyfriend, who has gracefully come along with me on this adventure, approaches holding a bottle of lube, he asks loud enough for anyone nearby to hear how much my medication cost.

"It was $43.00," I tell him, and he offers to pay half, putting his bottle of lube on the counter for purchase. I love him a little just then. He's helped bring me back to how very natural this process ought to be.

"If you have any problems at all, you can call us," the pharmacist offers. I give him a Fonz style double thumbs up and head to the door, wondering how the fuck people make it through these situations without hating themselves.

***

How much did I even know about Plan B before I spent a day trying to procure some? Very little. I had breezed through a few internet forums about how it works, but for some reason my head was quite stuck in thinking of it as a mini-abortion. All of the hubbub in the media about this controversial new form of contraception had made me believe that this little box of two super charged hormonal pills was something it was not. Beyond that, I thought purchasing it would be as easy as buying smokes was back when I was sixteen.

The most important thing I have learned because of my work with Midwest Teen Sex Show has had very little to do with sex or even teen sexuality itself. The most prominent among my findings is my realization that, even in knowing more than the average American consumer about sex, I don't know a goddam thing.


. . . . .
141 comments
Please login or register to post comments...

Nikol,

I really enjoyed your story and truly appreciate your writing style. You very much get the reader to "come along" with you for the ride.

However, I am aghast at the levity you bring to such a serious topic.

At the end of your blog, in referring to using Plan B, you say your "head was quite stuck in thinking of it as a mini-abortion". (You make this all sound so cute and trivial.) Plan B does not cause a mini-abortion; it causes an abortion. (Would you also joke about someone having a mini-brain tumor or mini-leukemia?) How dare you trivialize such a thing? In taking this drug you end a human life--there is nothing more important than that! This unborn baby will never see the light of day, be held by his or her mother or father, smile, run through the grass, go to school, or raise a family.

You also mention that there are a "whole slew of reasons a woman might find herself in need of a morning after pill" but I can't think of one. How could a girl/woman have an unplanned pregnancy? Wouldn't you agree these girls/women understand that intercourse is the cause of pregnancy? Where's the mystery?

Then, and with even a hint of smugness detected, you say you "regularly tell teens and young adults to always use protection, and tell girls of reproductive age who aren't so into the whole reproduction thing that they should be on birth control." Don't you think your efforts might be better spent telling these all-too-young-for-sex adolescents to just keep their clothes on and study or go to a movie or do something constructive?

I work with a lot of teens and young adults, too, and I just don't see that they are ready to embark on the most intense and deep issues of sexual intimacy. How can that be good for someone so young?

Also, just the fact that you get these "kids" on birth control--that fact alone--tells them to simply "go for it", have all the sex you want as there are no consequences. Well, I can think of two everlasting and life-altering consequences:

(1) Loss of innocence (what ever happened to a kid being a kid anymore?)
(2) Abortion ("accidents" happen, like you say: "condoms break, come off, etc" and so now what do you do? Resort to killing an innocent unborn little one to "clean up the mess"? Why does he/she have to pay the ultimate price for his/her mother's and father's misguided actions with the totality of his/her life? Could you mini-kill one of your three little children, Nikol?

What can we do to bring back a more wholesome way of living--especially for the young? Shall we simply give up and continue to pass out band-aids (contraception) or instead work to create the mindset of waiting (abstinence)? I pray every day that folks like you will make an everlasting positive impact on the youth. Your thoughts?

Submitted by Tommy on August 12, 2008 - 2:41am.

If we can't talk about these topics with humor and intelligence, most people will tune us out.  You can actually educate better with honey than vinegar.

 

Plan B, by the way, prevents any kind of embryonic life from being formed.  It works the same way as the birth control pill, by stopping ovulation.

 

As for the more wholesome way of living, how do you know how people in the past lived?  You weren't there.  There's strong evidence that they had sex for fun, though.  I know, shocking.  Your church told you that before 1960, people only did it once a month, and it was a grim march towards conception.  But if you get out and read some, you'll find people have never been "wholesome", and they've always had sex because it feels good.

Submitted by Amanda Marcotte, RH Reality Check on August 12, 2008 - 3:07pm.

Plan B, by the way, prevents any kind of embryonic life from being formed.

"The active ingredients in morning-after pills are similar to those in birth control pills, except in higher doses. Some morning-after pills contain only one hormone, levonorgestrel (Plan B), and others contain two, progestin and estrogen. Progestin prevents the sperm from reaching the egg and keeps a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus (implantation). Estrogen stops the ovaries from releasing eggs (ovulation) that can be fertilized by sperm."

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/morning-after-pill/AN00592

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 6:02pm.

Read through your post again. Amanda said:

Plan B, by the way, prevents any kind of embryonic life from being formed

morning-after pills contain only one hormone, levonorgestrel (Plan B), and others contain two, progestin and estrogen.

Progestin prevents the sperm from reaching the egg and keeps a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus

Plan B does not contain Progestin. There is no scientific evidence that Plan B (Levonorgestrel) prevents implantation.

Amanda's statement was 100% correct.

Even if Plan B was a progestin/esrogen combo, the ovulation-suppression of the estrogen would imply that, given implantation's natural 40%+ failure rate, even if progestin were 100% effective in preventing implantation, a woman taking such a pill drastically reduces her chance of losing a fertilized embryo.

Submitted by DL on August 12, 2008 - 6:19pm.

Take up your argument with Mayo Clinic. I'm just citing reputable sources that you might recognize.

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 6:31pm.

Do you have a problem with reading comprehension?


The Mayo Clinic concurs with Amanda.


The quote you presented cannot in any way be construed to mean that Plan B prevents implantation.

Submitted by DL on August 12, 2008 - 7:36pm.

others contain two, progestin and estrogen. Progestin prevents the sperm from reaching the egg and keeps a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus (implantation).

Contains progestin -- keeps a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus.

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 9:00pm.

How do the PREVEN® emergency contraceptive pills prevent pregnancy?
PREVEN® can stop or delay ovulation (the release of an egg), it can stop sperm from fertilizing an egg if it was already released, and it can stop a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus."
Source: http://www.drugs.com/mtm/preven-ec.html

How Does Plan B® Work?
Plan B® (levonorgestrel) may prevent pregnancy by temporarily stopping the release of an egg from a woman's ovary, or it may prevent fertilization. It may also prevent a fertilized egg from attaching to the uterus. "
Source: http://www.go2planb.com/ForConsumers/AboutPlanB/HowItWorks.aspx

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 9:34pm.

Lucille, did you ignore the study I posted about the effects of Levonorgestrel pre- and post-ovulation? Levonorgestrel was conjectured to prevent implantation, but there is no scientific evidence that this is the case


Second, Amanda made a statement about Plan B, not Preven.


Third, both of these pills actually reduce the chance that a woman will lose a fertilized egg. Drastically. Run the numbers yourself.

Submitted by DL on August 13, 2008 - 4:52am.

3. How does Plan B work?

Plan B works like other birth control pills to prevent pregnancy. Plan B acts primarily by stopping the release of an egg from the ovary (ovulation). It may prevent the union of sperm and egg (fertilization). If fertilization does occur, Plan B may prevent a fertilized egg from attaching to the womb (implantation). If a fertilized egg is implanted prior to taking Plan B, Plan B will not work.

http://www.fda.gov/CDER/DRUG/infopage/planB/planBQandA.htm

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 9:46pm.

By definition, a fertilized egg is not an embryo until implantation.

Submitted by mister slim on August 13, 2008 - 4:20am.

Look another "may". If you click on the study I linked to, you'll find that the conjecture that Plan B worked by preventing implantation turned out to be unfounded. There is no scientific evidence that it does such a thing.

By contrast, things like aerobics and coffee are well-known to decrease the chance of implantation and increase the risk of spontaneous abortion.

Submitted by DL on August 13, 2008 - 4:59am.

To Amanda’s Fan Club:

Amanda said, “Plan B prevents any kind of embryonic life from being formed.”
Mayo Clinic said, “Plan B. . .prevents a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus.”
DL said, “Amanda made a statement about Plan B, not Preven.”
I say, “Why do you bring that up? We are talking about Plan B.”
Definition of embryo says, “The term “embryo” is only used to refer to eukaryote organisms, otherwise known as multicellular organisms. Typically, people use the term specifically to refer to diploid eukaryotes, meaning that the embryo has a complete set of genetic material from two donors.”

Here’s a little riddle for you—Who said this? “The more we say it, the more people get to believing it. We’re changing the norm. First they laugh and then they start repeating it.”

So, DL, the answer to your question about why I didn’t check your link is this: There are so many links I couldn’t possibly know to which one you refer, AND, if your links play fast and loose with the facts as you do, they are useless.

NOW FOR THE RIDDLE!!! Could it be a friend of yours? Could it be the m.o. of participants at a meeting called by The Global Justice Center, started as a project of Women’s Link Worldwide, which was founded by the pro-abortion advocacy group The Center for Reproductive Rights, an organization that seeks to create an international human right to abortion on demand through litigation. Word has it GJC's plan is to exploit ceasefire and peace talks to gain leverage in newly-formed governments. So much for getting input from women about what women around the world want and need! I guess you guys represent the new imperialism. Maybe if the whole world has a 30% (per woman) abortion rate, you will then feel justified. That's quite a religion you have brewing.

Amanda, I hope you don't spend your whole life like this.

Submitted by Lucille on August 15, 2008 - 12:41pm.

From Danforth's Obstetrics and Gynecology textbook, defined here with respect to pregnancy loss:

Early pregnancy loss is more precisely defined as preembryonic (conception through the first 5 weeks of pregnancy from the first day of the last menstrual period), embryonic (6 to 9 weeks gestation), or fetal (10 weeks until delivery).
-
By this definition, Plan B does prevent any embryonic life from forming. And yes, I know you're going to start screaming about the "arbitrariness" of the definition. However, I choose to accept the definition proposed by the very profession that does the most to care for embryos and fetuses.

Submitted by Dr. Dredd on August 15, 2008 - 2:32pm.

Your quote from the Mayo clinic:

“Plan B. . .prevents a fertilized egg from attaching to the wall of the uterus.”

So what's in the ellipsis?

and others contain two, progestin and estrogen. Progestin prevents the sperm from reaching the egg and

So apparently you don't think the fact that they're talking about a completely different drug is relevant to preserving the substance of the quote?

What a transparent, blatant lie. By their fruits shall you know them, indeed.

So, DL, the answer to your question about why I didn’t check your link is this: There are so many links I couldn’t possibly know to which one you refer, AND, if your links play fast and loose with the facts as you do, they are useless.

If you missed it, here it is again.

Now I challenge you to show a single fact I have "played fast and loose with". Go ahead. I have already caught you in more than one blatant lie, so I don't expect an honest response.

NOW FOR THE RIDDLE!!! Could it be a friend of yours? Could it be the m.o. of participants at a meeting called by The Global Justice Center, started as a project of Women’s Link Worldwide, which was founded by the pro-abortion advocacy group The Center for Reproductive Rights, an organization that seeks to create an international human right to abortion on demand through litigation

It's from the University of Sydney department of obstetrics and gynecology. Do you want another one?

Instituto Nacional de Ciencias Médicas y Nutrición Salvador Zubirán, Mexico City, Mexico

In addition, peri- and post-ovulatory administration of LNG did not impair corpus luteum function or endometrial morphology.

Do you have any studies that contradict them, or are you going to persist in your belief that the entire scientific community is conspiring against you? Perhaps you should avail yourself of an aluminum foil helmet; I hear they're great for promoting abstinence in their wearers.

I don't want women to have abortions. I want them to have access to them should they need them, but mostly I want women to choose if and when they want to become pregnant. For some reason, no matter how much that gets pointed out, it just keeps bouncing off your skull.

Now, have you come up with an explanation as to why you'd be against a pill that reduces a woman's chance of losing a fertilized egg by an order of magnitude?

Submitted by DL on August 15, 2008 - 5:39pm.

If you do your research you'll know that abortion happens worldwide, even in countries where it's illegal. In countries where it's illegal, it presents serious health risks or even kills the mother. And when the mother dies, so does your precious little embryo. Twice the death-- is it really worth it?

Making abortion legal in other countries doesn't force women to get abortions, it simply means they aren't going to get one from Dan Down The Street With His Pliers

I'm not pro-abortion. I don't think abortion is the right choice for everyone. I don't think some people should, absolutely, in all situations, get an abortion. Were I to have an unplanned pregnancy (highly unlikely, given how meticulous I am about birth control-- funny, I thought you said birth control causes abortions?) it's not the choice I would make.

But I do think that abortions should be safe, and the only way they'll ever be remotely safe is if they're legal.

Submitted by Abortion should be legal. on August 29, 2008 - 1:04am.

You do realize Amanda never once replied to this? She's not a cult leader because some people agreed with her.

Submitted by Leah on August 30, 2008 - 5:11pm.

How do you know what churcxh, if any, the writer goes to? Maybe she was just raised in a modest household...while I agree that most Churhces preached "sex only for procreation" (as many still do)...it was also an accepted cultural idea for a long time...thanks to the sexual revolution of the 60's and 70's...and then the AIDS epidemic we are SITLL facing...sex is changing and so are we. Thank GOODNESS

Submitted by Anonymous on September 30, 2008 - 10:26pm.

Tommy, are you a mini-brained moron? Plan B does NOT cause abortions any more than birth-contol pills do.
If you don't like the subject matter STAY OFF THE SITE! Stick to your born-again crap sites-- We are into reality here.

Submitted by Morgan on August 13, 2008 - 10:04pm.

Little Tommy said :"You also mention that there are a "whole slew of reasons a woman might find herself in need of a morning after pill" but I can't think of one" - how about Rape, little Tommy, ever hear of that? How about a drunk hubby coming home to his sleeping wife and wanting a little action? How about a girl getting "roofies" in her drink and waking up with no clothes on at some guy's house? How about... you get the picture yet, ya little moron?

Submitted by Walt on August 14, 2008 - 5:33am.

Walt,

In addition to having your daughter stock up with Plan B, be sure to spend a minute or two teaching her how to avoid situations that could make her more vulnerable to being a crime victim. Also, give her a little guidance in selecting a worthy husband.

Or maybe simply stocking up on Plan B is just easier.

Submitted by lucille on August 20, 2008 - 3:29pm.

I'm just curious if you are implying that woman out there TRY to get raped? or purposefully choose a husband that will take up drinking and rape them? Horrifying incidences can occur anywhere. The fact that you sit by saying "make them less vulnerable" is disgusting in my view. Perfectly stong women can have terrifying instances occur and it is NOT THEIR FAULT.

Submitted by Anonymous on August 24, 2008 - 1:13am.

thats quite amazing.
I agree.

Submitted by Catie on October 13, 2008 - 4:57pm.

Plan B is not an abortion. If you choose to ignore the science behind it, of course you will continue to believe that it is an abortion. Plan B simply prevents the egg from implanting in the uterus, if it has already implanted Plan B will not harm the embryo.

Of course we should encourage abstinence, but we should also teach alternatives that are safe and healthy, such as birth control, so that when people decide to have sex that they are prepared.

Your tone of having a moral high ground on the subject makes your points weak. People are going to make their own decisions, the least we can do is give the scientific facts and not distort the truth.

Submitted by Anonymous on August 15, 2008 - 12:25am.

Tommy says that he "can't think of" a reason why a "girl/woman" would need the morning after or Plan B pill.
This is because Tommy is a male; taking no responsibility for reproductive responsibility and putting the onus solely on the female.
Tommy, have you heard of (or perhaps been guilty of) "date-rape"? or, how about forceful or violent sexual assault? incest? gang rape? a female, especially a girl, is no match for a determined group of sexual predators. and pregnancy is not the males' problem, anyways.
Or, there is the condom breaking, the diaphragm failing, many alternate scenarios of responsible birth control failing.
Your view of young females as lustful whores who will only abstain from sex for fear of pregnancy or STDs is sexist, ignorant, and insulting. You owe an apology to all young women struggling to develop a sense of self in this society which exploits the images of women as purely sexual objects or obedient matroids (matron + android).
I have worked with children who are the "accidental" result of incest. They often have disabilities (retardation, blindness, deafness, etc.); they always have severe emotional and psychological distress/trauma from being raised by a "girl/woman" who was not only violated and abused but was then forced to bear and raise that "accident". The male may or may not be incarcerated, and society gives him a slap on the wrist while expecting the victim to be a suffering saint. otherwise, she's a terrible mother, and by extension, a terrible person, right?
Wrong. You are the terrible person, Tommy.
Human social and sexual interactions are a lot more complex than the "she spread her legs, she hatches the eggs" mentality that you demonstrate.
I pray that you are sterile, or at least have no daughters.

Submitted by bunoid on August 15, 2008 - 4:39pm.

Dear Tommy,

First of all, of course, you have the right to voice your opinion. Abortion, unfortunately, will be a never ending controversy.

I would recommend reading up a little on Plan B before harshly criticizing Nikol for her pro-education endeavors. Plan B is meant to be taken immediately (within 1-2 days) after an accident. It prevents the egg from being fertilized. So, if you believe that life begins at conception, then, if used correctly and timely (I touch on education below), nothing has been conceived to abort.

Next, you wonder how might a "girl/woman have an unplanned pregnancy?" Lack of education, my friend. It's true that most girls/women know where babies come from, but they are uninformed on how to prevent them. I was a pregnant teenager in South Dakota. A good Christian girl that played sports, got A's, watched movies, read books and did many "constructive" activities, if that means anything to you. Unfortunately, my sexual education in school consisted of my PE teacher saying, "Don't have sex, don't have sex, you'll get an STD, you'll get pregnant, you may die, don't have sex." It sure did me a lot of good. When abstinence is taught in schools, and communities have no education programs for sexually curious young people, girls get pregnant. And when perfect adults who've never made mistakes pass judgment on the uneducated decisions of young girls, abortions happen. Let's get to the root of the problem, shall we? Education. Sure, let's encourage abstinence because, you're right, they aren't ready for sexual intimacy. Most importantly, we must also teach them what to do and how to be safe if and when they decide to have sex.

Introducing teenagers to birth-control/condoms does not mean you're giving them a green light, although, they will ultimately do what they want anyway. What we are doing is handling a sensitive and oh-so-important situation with respect for them (treating them like the adults they think they are) and in an adult matter. Let's be positive, healthy role models. They need to see adults talking about sex like adults, laying out all of their options and the consequences of those options.

Contraception education isn't a "band-aid." It's more like a vitamin.

Submitted by eliz.a on August 15, 2008 - 5:41pm.

Have you even seen the show, you really have no idea what its about do you? And I am a tolerant person, but really, abstinence?
Its just silly, truly it is. If you could feel some compassion for the poor girl who got knocked up, rather than the embryo, which according to the biological definition of life, is not alive, you might get farther. Contraception and safe sex are the only real options for teaching teens, because unless your Amish, or just have no concept of fun, abstinence ain't for you.

Submitted by Will newsom on August 18, 2008 - 12:39pm.

Maybe you should watch the show. Nikol never tells kids to blatantly go out there and have sex. The point of the show is to inform those who do, and even those who don't. The Midwest Teen Sex Show is for kids who, maybe, got the sex talk, but it didn't really hit home. It's for the questions that teens may still have that they are uncomfortable to ask. It's not about 'going out there and getting laid,' it's about being informed. And, if you so support the abstinence movement, I hope you never have children, because they will be the first to go out there and do the dirty. I AM a teen/young adult and I'm a virgin, but what most people over the age of forty fail to grasp is the fact that there always will be teens who go out there and have sex, no matter what is taught in schools or what people like Nikol put on their web show. You should bless her soul because she is trying to keep kids away from having to have abortions.

Submitted by a loyal supporter on August 24, 2008 - 12:51am.

I am particularly interested in the line "loss of innocence." Innocence is a pretty controvercial term in my eyes. Are you implying that once a couple is married and has sex that they are no longer "innocent?" If you have ever walked down a school hallway it should have become apparent that kids don't act or talk innocent in the least. They talk about every dirty thing that even my own parents are too shy to talk about, and many of them are virgins. And personally, I connect innocence to the commiting of crimes, and I don't know about you, but i don't think it's intelligent to claim that sex is a crime, especially when it is what brought you into existence. Maybe I'm wrong, and it is all opinions anyways, but I will never believe my teenage sexually active friends are no longer "innocent," and i hope that if they ever believe that they have the slightest chance of being pregnant that they will use Plan B which is to be used before the sperm fertilizes the egg than for them to parent a child at so young an age, or to get an abortion.

Submitted by Anonymous on August 24, 2008 - 1:01am.

by the way the previous post i left was for all the anti people u know anti abortion, plan b, that stuff

nikole u rule keep finding stuff out knowledge is power and help us all learn so were not a close minded preacher type idiot like tommy

open ur mind and step out side ur comfort zone once and a awhile and u may not be offended that often

Submitted by andrew mayville on August 25, 2008 - 2:36am.

Well, I have to add my reply to this.
1. Plan B, or emergency contraception does not cause an abortion. It, like the hormonal birth controls, prevents ovulation. If the woman has already ovulated, It is still probable that that pregnancy will go forth as unplanned, though like other hormonal methods the uterine lining will also be changed possible preventing a fertilized egg from implanting. So I have to ask, does this make the Pill an abortificant?

2. Unplanned pregnancies happen. Its no mystery how a woman becomes pregnant, but we take precautions to lessen the chance of pregnancy when we are not ready for a baby. But they happen. The IUD was silently expelled, the woman was not informed she had to take the pill at the exact same time, the ring was expelled, the patch fell off, ect. Would you have a grown woman who is married, or in a similarly committed relationship not have sex with her partner?

3. Sex happens, teenagers and adults all have urges and needs that need to be fulfilled. And I've never heard a sex educator tell anyone they should have sex whenever they want. I have heard them talk in detail about abstinence, about protection from STIs and pregnancy. But, as has happened for thousands of years, teens will have sex. Teens will find themselves pregnant unexpectedly. It does great harm to teach about abstinence Only, and not teaching how to reduce risks.

4. Which good ol days would you like to return to? As a historian I have to ask? The days of the 50s? When political witch hunts for Communists took Place? Women were told their place was in the home? And Demonized for taking jobs from men? The 1800s? Where women had few rights to leave an abusive marriage? Couldn't vote? Where women in many cases were chatel? Oh and if we go back much farther than the mid 1800's where abortion was perfectly legal?

5. Sex is going to happen, its part of human nature, its something that's turned on at puberty. You can't prevent it, you can't stop it. Its a beautiful part of being human. Its time we embraced it in this country rather than deny it. Get good education, good information out there on sex and prevention of the consequences of sex. I commend most sex educators for their work, and hope that those educators giving out fear and misinformation don't make a lasting impact.

Submitted by Anonymous on August 26, 2008 - 4:09pm.

I love that you went and tried to get "Plan B", Nikol. Sometimes it's just nescessary but I hope I never have to go through that ordeal.

Tommy, I'm sorry to say, I disagree with you on a lot of what you said. It's one sided and a little (a lot) bigoted. Now, I may be only a "rebellious, misguided" teen, but, I think if you were a woman in that situation and had people judging you, you might understand the choices behind it a bit better. I've been on birth control for 3 years now, that way I'm ready when I feel like I'm ready. My friend, unfortunately, has not made the same choices as I have. I don't judge her, but I do help her make these decisions. Some are difficult, and a few involved Planned Parenthood.

Please, if you're going to open your mouth, or start typing anything at all, look at both sides of an issue. If you're a man, remember that it's not your body. It's the woman's and her choice, so let her choose. If you're a woman, don't let anyone pressure you. Not the church, not the media, not your friends, not the father and definately not anyone who sneers at you and acts as though you were any less of a person for your choice. If I was, say, raped and unsure as to whether I'd get pregnant or not, I'd use "Plan B". If I knew that my body was not healthy enough to support a child, I'd use "Plan B".

Lastly, I made the decision to at least wait until I reach the legal age of consent. Some "kids" choose to have sex the moment they feel like they met "the one". Childhood is relative. Some people mature quickly, some don't. You can only treat us like "kids" for so long before we choose to live for ourselves, and once we do, there's not much that will change our minds.

Sincerely,
Karin

Submitted by Karin on September 14, 2008 - 9:33pm.

There's one real answer to solving these problems. Close your legs.

Submitted by wow on November 2, 2008 - 10:46pm.

Plan B is not an abortion of any type. It prevents ovulation. It does not prevent implantation of a fertilized embryo. Since sperm live up to 5 days (yuck) inside the body, taking plan B will prevent you from ovulating while there is spermies swimming around inside you. If however, you have already ovulated and a sperm swum up in that little egg, your outta luck.

Do the freakin' research before you go acting like you know about what your talking about. Read the studies. Plan B does not prevent implantation.

I'm so tired of people who can't be bothered to freaking read having a gotsdamed opinion on everything.

Submitted by Anonymous on September 15, 2008 - 1:34am.

As a 16 year old "young adult" I have to say that some of your comments are very offensive.
In my opinion, kids my age really need to be educated about sex and its consequences. It is becoming more of an epidemic, and if you are going to have the media glorify sex, then you need to educate the viewers what it is really about.
As well as this, I have discovered that if an adult, or someone I just really don't like has told me not to do something, the first thing I want to do, is do it. From personal experience, most people who are told to use protection are already sexually active, so in advising the use of protection, it is reducing an already potential risk.
You mention that you should just tell kids to remain abstinent, but the fact is, is they are subjected to the message that sex is okay, and they are going to believe it. No matter how much you tell them not to have sex, they are still going to go out and do it. It is what we are hard-wired to do. Therefore it is better to inform them of how to be safe. Plus, when you talk about safety, it almost inevitably leads to the subject of Sexually Transmitted Diseases, and that alone is enough to scare some people from having sex at an early age.
As for the plan b, there ARE reasons to take it. It doesn't just apply to consensual sex. Two of my friends have been raped, and thank god for plan b, because they would have been REALLY screwed up if they didn't have it.
Also, plan b does not necessarily kill an unborn baby, the purpose is to prevent a pregnancy.
It says right on the front of the box, "reduces the chance of pregnancy after unprotected sex". Furthermore, on the back it says "Do not use: If you are already pregnant (because it will not work)".
Also, I must say that your comment "Could you mini-kill one of your three little children, Nikol?" is a bit over the top. So, she is pro-choice, that's her opinion. And guess what, when it came to her children, she CHOSE life.
In conclusion, you need to get all your facts straight, and stop being such a "holier than thou prick". It sounds like you haven't experienced what it is like to be a teenager in a while. No matter how much you work with them, you wont truly know all the pressure and stress people like you put us under. Its people like Nikol, and programs like MTSS that help us be more wise, less stressed.

sorry, I kind of ranted.

Submitted by Anonymous on September 18, 2008 - 11:18pm.

I would just like to mention that I made general statements about the common actions among young adults, and that I do realize that there are people my age that do not go out and have sex. I also would like to point out that I don't think that everyone... young or old, or anywhere in between... should just go around having sex with anyone. it is a very serious action to participate in, I just don't think that you should tell young adults to flat out not have sex. I think it is more important to express the consequences.
As is described by the original article, it is widely looked down upon to use contraceptives, and when necessary plan b. Which is very sad, because for a country that is supposed to be open minded about peoples beliefs, it seems very close minded. Plus, why should society in general make it so hard for people to be safe. It is a morning after pill, and yet it is nearly impossible to get it the morning after.
My advice to those who are sexually active, and would hypothetically plan on using plan b if they were to have an "accident" is to get it now. That way it is available to you if you need it, and you don't have to have the stress of not being able to get it in time.
I got mine from planned parenthood when I got my birth control. (I live in CA if that makes a difference)

Submitted by Anonymous on September 19, 2008 - 12:41am.

This article is suppose to be informative. It is suppose to bring light to the tragic state of women's right. A woman who actually needs the pill is going to have to go through hell to find it. The further south and more religious your neighborhood the harder the hunt for "Plan B" will be. You will be denied your right, your choice because some asshole behind the counter doesn't feel its moral. Thats not his place ,not your place. No one wants to hear a speech when they are trying to keep their life from falling apart. And can it with the whole abstaining bit. It doesn't work! I am a teenager I would know. I took the class and got the card. You can't use scare tactics to curve human nature.And getting on birth control isn't the loss of innocence it is called thinking ahead and being responsible. Everyone lives different lives so get off your pedal stool and get into the real world. Thanks.

Submitted by Tatum on September 28, 2008 - 11:10am.

I have difficulty perceiving a fertilized egg as a "human" when I just killed a bug in my room with 1,000 times more cells than the egg.

Submitted by Brad on October 27, 2008 - 12:17pm.

Tommy, I don't really think you have any right to judge what women do. You (seemingly) aren't a woman, and shall never have to carry or raise a child on your own, so I don't see why you think that your opinion on the subject matters. Religious beliefs have nothing to do with practicing safe sex, and taking care of accidents early enough to prevent the NEED for abortion is much better for everyone involved, mom and non-existent child. Not everyone who has an accident is a godless baby killer. They may just be between a rock and a hard place, and are taking Plan B to prevent a child they don't want or simply cannot take care of. It isn't a form of abortion, but rather pregnancy prevention through tricking the body into believing that it is already carrying a child.
Get your facts right, and stop judging people. You'll do what you do best, whine. And they'll do what they do best, ignore you.

Submitted by Brooke on November 5, 2008 - 8:01pm.

You also mention that there are a "whole slew of reasons a woman might find herself in need of a morning after pill" but I can't think of one.

Um, how about rape?

Submitted by Anonymous on August 12, 2008 - 9:31am.

There is no denying that rape is a serious and grievous act and that the rapist should be punished. But, even in such a horrendous act a human being may be conceived. Why should this little one be punished, too, and have his/her life taken away? Cannot good come from evil? Who is to judge that this life is not worthy of being brought to term and given a chance to bring some light to the darkness?

I would expect that the mother may not want to keep and raise this child, so would want to offer him/her up for adoption. You may have heard that "two wrongs do not make a right". I believe that applies in this situation.

Submitted by Tommy on August 12, 2008 - 10:00am.

Tommy: certainly some women who become pregnant through sexual assault do choose to sustain their pregnancies and then parent or place a child up for adoption. And certainly, some women have had the experience that a child -- more so than a pregnancy, which I'll talk about in a sec -- is something good to come out of something terrible.

However, you may or many not be aware, for instance, of the fact that for sexual assault victims, pregnancy and delivery are often particularly difficult since they can be very triggering when it comes to body memories and other PTSD issues. If you have never been the victim of a sexual assault yourself, this may seem minor or like no big shakes, but if you read the words of those who have been victimized, one'd hope you'd privilege those words coming from a place of experience and pretty easily see what I am talking about.

That is often the case even for women whose pregnancies are not a result of assault. As well, to have a birth, one must have a pregnancy, and for plenty of assaulted women, they not only do not want to remain pregnant -- and suggesting one more thing should be forced on them via something which was forced already is pretty troublesome, especially coming from someone who has never been pregnant themselves and cannot become so -- but cannot afford to be so (being raped doesn't somehow make you magically financially capable of sustaining a pregnancy or raising a child), do not want another reminder of the trauma every waking minute of the day, and also do not want to bring a child into the world which came in part from a rapist.

Women who choose to use EC or who choose to abort are often well aware of their capabilities and limitations and often make these choices based not only for their own best interest, but out of what is felt to be in a child's best interest. And around here, rape or no rape, and certainly in the reproductive and women's health community, you're going to find that most of us feel that women are EXACTLY who is to judge what she wants to do with her own body and anything dependent upon it and what she feels is best for any children she may or may not bring into the world.

And if you can't trust a woman's judgment when it comes to making choices about pregnancy, it seems pretty strange to suggest that she should be entrusted with all the choices and responsibilities involved in parenting.

Submitted by Heather C. on August 12, 2008 - 10:49am.

...the fact that some women also very much do not want to have to be tied or linked to their rapists in any way or have a child subjected to that person in any way, either. Let's not forget that being a rapist doesn't often relinquish a person's parental rights.

Submitted by Heather C. on August 12, 2008 - 10:55am.

I have to seriously second Heather on everything she says.

When my period was late after being assaulted, I felt so ill I couldn't bring my eyes to focus on anything. In the end, I believe it was the stress of the assault itself that caused the late period, but I knew I could not bear the thought of bringing my rapist's child into the world. I had always had the stance on abortion that I wanted it to be an available choice for women, but that I would never get one myself. That feeling of true terror at the thought of having my rapist's child changed all of that in a matter of hours. On at least some level, I felt would have rather died than be responsible for bringing his child into the world. When the mental anguish is that extreme, I don't know how anyone could reasonably deny a woman the right to make the choice to get EC or an abortion. All I can say is that if you haven't been in the situation, you don't know what it's like and have no right to tell a woman that her decision was wrong if she truly believed she was acting in her own best interests.

The issue of assault aside, I believe that it is even less fair to bring a child into the world when you know you cannot adequately provide for it (or yourself, during the pregnancy, thus putting a fetus at risk for all sorts of health problems), than it is to prevent it from coming into the world in the first place. Getting EC right away is one of the most responsible things a person can do if they are concerned about a potential pregnancy, because it prevents the pregnancy before it even starts and is a lot easier on the mother's body than an abortion, which itself carries fewer risks of complications than full term pregnancy and childbirth.

If we lived in a place where all women could know that they are guaranteed quality health care and adequate financial support to carry a pregnancy to term, I still don't believe that arguments like Tommy's would hold any water. Being pregnant is certainly not a walk in the park, no matter how good and available medical care is.

The fact that Plan B is so hard to come by over the counter is definitely alarming, though I find the fact that a medical professional would turn down a woman seeking medical care because she was looking for EC even more alarming. I'd like to believe that experiences like this are an exception, not the norm, though I doubt that's true.

Submitted by Anonymous on August 12, 2008 - 11:28am.

Unfortunately, a rapist is probably not overly concerned about his child. What an awful situation for you. Perhaps giving birth and bestowing a child on an infertile couple might have been therapeutic for you, a heroic act to help balance out the suffering in the world.

Check out the Mayo Clinic website to see how the morning-after pill actually works.

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 6:14pm.

Rape is an intentional abuse, and one often largely about power and control. People seeking to control others are often delighted to have more ways to control or to have more individuals they can control. I certainly wouldn't call that concern for a child, however they needn't be concerned for the child to involve themselves with them where the law allows.

You can look around the web alone and note plenty of cases where, in fact, rapists have indeed sought out custody in states where they have that right. As well, adoption requires the consent of BOTH parents, and rapists have blocked victims from placing children for adoption in the past, sometimes even blackmailing them by stating they will relinquish their parental rights if their victim drops charges.

And while there are many other reasons a woman may seek to prevent (or terminate, when we're talking about abortion rather than EC) a pregnancy, and many reasons a woman who has lived through rape will do so, not taking the chance that their rapist may try to become involved or be involved with their pregnancy or their child certainly is one. Even if we set aside concerns for a child, which are often paramount, if you have ever had to sit and have a chat or a legal battle with someone who sexually violated you or otherwise abused you, you surely know that this is something many people want to avoid.

If you've additional interest in this issue, there was also an excellent piece on it right here at RH some months ago: http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2008/04/10/parental-rights-for-rapist...

Submitted by Heather C. on August 12, 2008 - 6:39pm.

My heroic act has been surviving what happened and learning to thrive in the world in spite, and because of what happened to me.

I didn't end up pregnant, and I'm eternal grateful for that. But some women aren't as lucky as me, and I hope that, no matter what your personal beliefs about what you might do in that situation, you'd respect the decisions a woman makes. I know that carrying a child to term would have made it impossible for me to keep going to school on time (I was 17 at the time, at the same high school as my rapist), and that each and every day it was inside of me, I would have wanted to rip it out.

If I had been able to get EC (and I'm not sure back then it was even available), I would have used it in a second to prevent that pain. If I had become pregnant, I would have terminated. And that would have been the right decision for me, and no one has any right to say otherwise.

Submitted by Anonymous (the same from 12:28) on August 12, 2008 - 7:02pm.

 Perhaps giving birth and bestowing a child on an infertile couple might have been therapeutic for you, a heroic act to help balance out the suffering in the world.

Foot-in-mouth disease:  An idea comes and it must be spoken—tact or guile yielding to childlike exuberanceInterestingly, this is a symptom of adult AD/HD... you may want to get that checked out.

In all seriousness, I hope that you were just goading with that comment.

Submitted by Mellankelly1 on August 12, 2008 - 7:36pm.

Maybe I have AD/HD. Or maybe all of you of the abortion religion could use some therapy, since you can't even think straight. Guilt can be a helpful thing, unless you ignore it.

Submitted by Lucille on August 12, 2008 - 9:39pm.

Maybe I have AD/HD. Or maybe all of you of the abortion religion could use some therapy, since you can't even think straight. Guilt can be a helpful thing, unless you ignore it.

Apparently you're of the mind that guilt is something that can be forced on a person simply because you find something to be icky.  Nope.  When no offense has been committed (like, say... having an opinion of ones own volition) guilt would be unwarranted.  Unhelpful guilt isn't good unless you're into that whole sadomasochism thing (I'm not judging... to each his or her own, right?).

Submitted by Mellankelly1 on August 12, 2008 - 9:57pm.